May 5 • Pratik Naik

The A24 AI Controversy: ‘Civil War’ Causes Battle Between Artistry and Artificial Intelligence

A24 Films, the renowned independent studio behind critically acclaimed hits like "Hereditary," "Ex Machina," and the Oscar-winning "Everything Everywhere All At Once," has recently stirred up significant controversy with its foray into big-budget filmmaking. The issue centers around the use of artificial intelligence (AI) to create promotional materials for their latest movie, "Civil War." Let's take a closer look at the controversy and its implications for actors and creatives in the film industry.

Innovative Promotion or Misleading Tactics?

In April, A24 unveiled a series of AI-generated promotional posters for "Civil War," Alex Garland's upcoming film portraying a dystopian future America embroiled in internal conflict. Instead of utilizing traditional graphic artists, A24 opted to use an AI image generator to create the posters. These images depict striking scenes of destruction in various American cities, from a burning Las Vegas to a war-torn New York. However, sources close to the production have confirmed that these scenes do not actually appear in the film itself.

Critics argue that this approach is not only misleading to potential viewers, as it suggests a scale of visual spectacle that the film's $50 million budget likely cannot deliver, but it also misrepresents the actual content of the movie. Moreover, the posters contained several telltale inaccuracies commonly found in AI-generated images, such as misaligned perspectives and oddly proportioned objects, which raise questions about the quality and authenticity of the marketing materials.
A24 and AI: Innovation or Threat?

While the use of AI in filmmaking is not a new phenomenon, with examples ranging from Marvel's AI-generated opening sequence in "Secret Invasion" to the AI-created art images in "Late Night With the Devil," A24's decision has come under particular scrutiny. During the 2023 Hollywood strikes, one of the key issues was the protection of creative jobs in the face of increasing AI usage, which many fear could replace human actors and artists.

Given A24's reputation for championing artist-driven, original content, many in the industry expected the studio to stand in solidarity with creatives during this pivotal moment. The choice to use AI for the "Civil War" posters has left many actors and artists questioning whether A24 truly values human artistry or sees AI as a more cost-effective and efficient alternative.

The film’s directors Cameron and Colin Cairnes responded to the use of AI, saying, “In conjunction with our amazing graphics and production design team, all of whom worked tirelessly to give this film the ’70s aesthetic we had always imagined, we experimented with AI for three still images which we edited further and ultimately appear as very brief interstitials in the film.”
Creatives Respond

The backlash from the creative community has been swift and vocal, with many taking to social media to express their disappointment and frustration. Comments range from criticizing the lack of authenticity and creative integrity in the AI-generated posters to expressing a sense of betrayal by A24 for failing to support the artists who have been instrumental to the studio's success. The controversy has underscored the growing tension in the entertainment industry between embracing technological advancements and preserving the crucial roles of human creators.

TikTok user "jacqueslaurentcote" expresses his thoughts on the topic: 
Looking Forward

As AI technology continues to evolve and become more sophisticated, its integration into various aspects of the filmmaking process seems inevitable. The challenge for studios like A24 will be finding a way to navigate this shifting landscape without alienating the talented individuals who have been the driving force behind their achievements. The ongoing debate extends beyond the scope of a single film or promotional campaign; it speaks to the broader question of the future of creative jobs in an increasingly AI-driven world.

The "Civil War" poster controversy represents a watershed moment for A24 and potentially a harbinger of things to come for the industry as a whole. The manner in which A24 and other studios address the concerns raised by creatives could establish important precedents for the use of AI in film production and promotion in the years ahead.

For the time being, the industry remains in a state of anticipation and uncertainty, hopeful that the promise of AI's efficiency will not come at the cost of undermining the irreplaceable value of human creativity.

About the Author

Pratik Naik

Pratik Naik is a leading visionary in retouching and photography who inspires and mentors professionals worldwide. As the founder of Infinite Color, he simplifies complex editing processes with innovative Photoshop plugins and tools. He shares his knowledge and expertise through workshops and online education, nurturing the next generation of creative minds.
Write your awesome label here.

Are you curious how Ai tools can enhance creativity and keep your business relevant in a rapidly evolving industry?

Check out Pratik's course, "Ai For Photographers," which simplifies the process of integrating Ai tools into your current workflow with clear steps.
Created with